Past simple vs present perfect: the rules, explained with examples
“I lost my keys” or “I have lost my keys”? Both sentences are correct, but they do not mean the same thing. This guide shows you how to choose. You will find the rules, the time words that help you, 22 pairs of example sentences and common mistakes.
How to make the two tenses
| Past simple | Present perfect | |
|---|---|---|
| Positive | She visited Peru. He went home. | She has visited Peru. They have gone home. |
| Negative | She didn’t visit Peru. | She hasn’t visited Peru. |
| Question | Did she visit Peru? | Has she visited Peru? |
The present perfect uses have or has + the past participle. For regular verbs, the participle ends in -ed. For irregular verbs, it is the third form: see – saw – seen.
When to use the past simple
Use the past simple when the action is finished and you are thinking about when it happened. The time is over.
- With a finished time: We moved here in 2018. I called her last night.
- For a story, one action after another: He opened the door, turned on the light and sat down.
- For questions with when or what time: When did you arrive?
Sometimes there is no time word, but both people know the time: Did you enjoy the party? (the party last Saturday).
When to use the present perfect
Use the present perfect when the past action is connected to now. You do not give a finished time.
- Life experience: I have eaten snails. Have you ever been to Egypt? She has never driven a car.
- A result you can see now: He has cut his hand. (It is bleeding now.)
- A time that is not finished: I have drunk three coffees today. (Today is not over.)
- Something that started in the past and continues now: They have lived in this house since 2010.
Is the time finished? Look at the clock
Words like today and this morning can take both tenses. It depends on the moment when you speak. At 10 a.m. you say I have had two meetings this morning, because the morning is not over. At 3 p.m. you say I had two meetings this morning, because the morning is finished.
A person’s life works in the same way. For a living person, say My aunt has written four books. For a person who is dead, say Agatha Christie wrote many detective stories.
Time words that help you choose
| Past simple | Present perfect |
|---|---|
| yesterday, last week, last year | ever, never, before |
| in 2015, in May, on Tuesday | since 2015, since May, since Tuesday |
| two days ago, a long time ago | so far, up to now, lately, recently (recently can take both) |
| when I was young, at six o’clock | today, this week, this year (if not finished) |
| When…? What time…? | How long…? Have you ever…? |
The rule: never use the present perfect with a finished time. I have seen her yesterday is wrong.
For and since
Both words answer the question How long?
| Word | Use it with | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| for | a length of time | for ten minutes, for three days, for a long time |
| since | the point when it started | since nine o’clock, since Monday, since I was a child |
Since goes with the present perfect: I have had this bike since March. For can go with both tenses, and the meaning changes. I worked there for a year means that the job is finished. I have worked there for a year means that it is still your job.
Been or gone?
My parents have been to Spain means they went and came back. They are at home now. My parents have gone to Spain means they are in Spain now, or on the way. For life experience, use been: Have you ever been to London?
News first, then details
People often give news in the present perfect and then change to the past simple for the details.
“I’ve found a new flat!” “Great! Where did you find it?” “I saw it online last week.”
Just, already and yet: British and American English
With these three words, British speakers normally use the present perfect. American speakers use the present perfect too, but they also often use the past simple. Both are correct.
| Word | Usual in British English | Also common in American English |
|---|---|---|
| just | I’ve just had lunch. | I just had lunch. |
| already | She’s already left. | She already left. |
| yet | Have you done it yet? | Did you do it yet? |
Yet is for questions and negatives, and it goes at the end: I haven’t paid yet.
22 example pairs
Read each pair and ask: is the time finished, or is there a connection to now?
| Past simple | Present perfect |
|---|---|
| I lost my keys yesterday. | I have lost my keys. (I can’t find them now.) |
| She lived in Rome for three years. (She left.) | She has lived in Rome for three years. (She is still there.) |
| Did you see Anna this morning? (It is now the afternoon.) | Have you seen Anna this morning? (It is still the morning.) |
| We went to Kenya in 2022. | We have been to Kenya twice. |
| He broke his leg last winter. | He has broken his leg, so he can’t play. |
| I read that book at school. | I have read that book. You can have it. |
| They got married in June. | They have been married since June. |
| It rained a lot last night. | It has rained a lot this week. |
| I didn’t eat breakfast today. (said in the evening) | I haven’t eaten breakfast yet. (said in the morning) |
| When did you start this job? | How long have you had this job? |
| She wrote three emails before lunch. | She has written three emails so far today. |
| My grandfather visited China many times. (He is dead.) | My sister has visited China many times. (She can go again.) |
| I knew him when we were children. | I have known him since we were children. |
| The train left ten minutes ago. | The train has just left. |
| Did you ride horses when you were young? | Have you ever ridden a horse? |
| We had that car for six years. (We sold it.) | We have had this car for six years. (It is still our car.) |
| Prices went up last year. | Prices have gone up. (They are high now.) |
| I worked late on Friday. | I have worked late every day this week. |
| He was ill last week. | He has been ill since Monday. |
| I saw that film on Saturday. | I have seen that film three times. |
| She finished the report an hour ago. | She has already finished the report. |
| Who painted this picture? (a finished event in the past) | Look! Someone has painted the door. (It is a new colour now.) |
Common mistakes
| Wrong | Right | Why |
|---|---|---|
| I have seen him yesterday. | I saw him yesterday. | Yesterday is a finished time. |
| I live here since 2020. | I have lived here since 2020. | Since needs the present perfect. |
| I know her for five years. | I have known her for five years. | It started in the past and continues now. |
| When have you arrived? | When did you arrive? | When asks about a finished time. |
| I have been born in 1999. | I was born in 1999. | Your birth is a finished event. |
| She has went out. | She has gone out. | Use the past participle after has. |
| I have lived here since two years. | I have lived here for two years. | Two years is a length of time. |
| He has gone to Japan twice. | He has been to Japan twice. | He came back, so use been. |
Quick answers
What is the difference between past simple and present perfect?
The past simple is for a finished action at a finished time: I saw her yesterday. The present perfect connects the past to now and does not say when: I have seen her before.
Can I use the present perfect with yesterday?
No. Yesterday, last week, in 2019 and two days ago are finished times, so they need the past simple. Say I went there yesterday, not I have gone there yesterday.
When do I use for and when do I use since?
Use for with a length of time: for two hours, for five years. Use since with the point when something started: since Monday, since 2015, since I was a child.
What is the difference between have been and have gone?
She has been to Paris means she went and came back. She has gone to Paris means she is in Paris now or on her way there. Use been to talk about life experience.
Do Americans use the present perfect?
Yes. But with just, already and yet, American speakers often use the past simple too: I already ate. British speakers normally say I have already eaten. Both are correct.